Wondering where the best places to eat Gettysburg are? Some of the dining spots are on the national register of historic places. Whether you’re in the mood for historic settings, modern cuisine, or authentic international dishes, this guide will direct you to the top dining spots in town. From the colonial charm of Dobbin House Tavern to the farm-fresh flavors at Hickory Bridge Farm Restaurant, we’ve got you covered.
Key Takeaways
Many visitors who ate at Dobbin House Tavern rave about its historic charm and traditional colonial dishes, making it a must-visit in Gettysburg’s oldest restaurant!
Indulge in exceptional dining at Sidney Willoughby Run, known for its high-quality steaks, inventive seafood, and extensive wine list!
Enjoy a festive atmosphere at The Garryowen Irish Pub, offering authentic Irish fare, live music, and a welcoming vibe!
Dobbin House Tavern
Experience history and hospitality at Dobbin House Tavern, Gettysburg’s oldest restaurant. Established in 1776, this iconic venue offers a colonial experience that transports you to a bygone era. Nestled near the site of Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address, its historical significance is evident as soon as you enter.
Dobbin House Tavern is listed on the national register of historic places, highlighting its historical importance. Dobbin House Tavern is more than a restaurant; it’s a historic landmark and one of the historic places to visit. The 18th-century home is meticulously restored with period furnishings and decor. Dining here feels like a living museum, each room providing a unique glimpse into colonial life. Whether in the cozy Springhouse Tavern or the formal Alexander Dobbin Dining Rooms, it’s an unforgettable experience.
The menu at Dobbin House Tavern features traditional colonial and continental dishes, made from fresh, high-quality ingredients. Savor hearty fare like roast duckling or prime rib in a setting that echoes the 18th century.
Each dining room offers a distinct atmosphere, from intimate nooks to grand, historic spaces, ensuring a memorable meal. Surrounded by rich history, Dobbin House Tavern is a must-visit destination in Gettysburg.
Sidney Willoughby Run
Sidney Willoughby Run offers a refined dining experience with high standards in food quality and customer service. The cozy, inviting ambiance suits both casual dining and special occasions, promising a memorable meal.
The menu at Sidney Willoughby Run is a testament to culinary excellence, featuring high-quality steaks and inventive seafood dishes. Diners praise the prix fixe menu for its generous portions and exquisite presentation. Many diners who ate at Sidney Willoughby Run praise the generous portions and exquisite presentation of the prix fixe menu. Whether enjoying a perfectly cooked steak or a creative seafood dish, each bite reflects the chef’s skill and dedication.
Adding to its allure is an extensive wine list, featuring 6,000 bottles and earning the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence. The attentive and knowledgeable staff ensure every detail is perfect. Whether for a quiet evening or a special celebration, Sidney Willoughby Run offers an elegant and unforgettable dining experience.
Herr Tavern & Publick House
Herr Tavern & Publick House, at 900 Chambersburg Road, is another gem in Gettysburg’s dining scene. This historic tavern combines historic charm with modern comfort, making it popular with both locals and visitors. Its rich history is evident in every corner, providing a unique dining backdrop.
Adding to its charm and appeal, Herr Tavern & Publick House is listed on the national register of historic places, highlighting its historical significance and connection to notable events from the Civil War.
Dining at Herr Tavern is a treat, with options for private events accommodating groups of 10 to 150 people. Whether planning an intimate dinner or a grand celebration, the tavern’s versatile spaces cater to your needs. Each dining room exudes historic charm, creating a cozy and elegant atmosphere.
The dining experience at Herr Tavern is enhanced by attentive service and a delectable menu. From hearty pub fare to refined dishes, there’s something for everyone. The historic ambiance, combined with modern amenities, makes it a must-visit for anyone exploring Gettysburg.
Hickory Bridge Farm Restaurant
For a traditional farm-to-table dining experience, visit Hickory Bridge Farm Restaurant. Located at 96 Hickory Bridge Road in Orrtanna, PA, this family-run establishment has served guests for three generations. The restaurant is housed in a historic barn, adding to its rustic charm and warm atmosphere.
Hickory Bridge Farm is renowned for traditional farm meals, with a seasonal menu that emphasizes local ingredients. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring freshness and flavor. From hearty roasts to fresh vegetables, the menu celebrates local bounty, making every meal a true farm-to-table experience.
A highlight of dining at Hickory Bridge Farm is the family-style dinners with unlimited portions. Genuine hospitality and a cozy setting make it perfect for a relaxed meal. The restaurant can accept reservations, and they are often necessary, especially on weekends, as this popular restaurant fills up quickly.
The Garryowen Irish Pub
For a taste of Ireland in Gettysburg, visit The Garryowen Irish Pub at 126 Chambersburg Street. This lively pub is known for authentic Irish fare and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether craving a pint of Guinness or a hearty meal, The Garryowen offers a true Irish pub experience.
The menu features classic Irish dishes, from shepherd’s pie to fish and chips, all made with authentic ingredients. The lively atmosphere, complete with live music and friendly service, makes it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family.
The Garryowen Irish Pub is a must-visit for anyone seeking Irish hospitality in the heart of Gettysburg.
Food 101
Food 101, located at 101 Chambersburg Street, offers a modern dining experience that is both inviting and innovative. The contemporary decor and cozy ambiance make it perfect for any dining occasion, from casual meals to special celebrations. The emphasis on fresh, locally sourced ingredients ensures each dish is flavorful and sustainable.
The menu at Food 101 celebrates seasonal produce, with options that change regularly to reflect the freshest ingredients. Diners can enjoy a variety of dishes, from salads and sandwiches to unique pizzas like the highly praised corn pancetta pizza. House specialties, such as the vegetable powerhouse sandwich on wheat berry bread, are complemented by house-made fries for a delicious, satisfying meal.
In addition to lunch and dinner, Food 101 offers an array of breakfast options, making it versatile for any time of day. Attentive service and a modern dining experience have earned the restaurant high praise, making it a standout choice in Gettysburg’s dining scene.
Whether enjoying a leisurely breakfast, quick lunch, or relaxed dinner, Food 101 provides a dining experience where you can eat that combines quality, flavor, and sustainability. The inviting atmosphere and commitment to fresh ingredients ensure every meal is memorable.
Appalachian Brewing Company
Located near a historic battlefield, Appalachian Brewing Company offers a unique dining experience that combines history with modern brewing. The spacious dining area and outdoor patio seating provide a comfortable setting for enjoying a meal and a pint of craft beer.
The brewpub features a state-of-the-art brewing system producing 150-gallon batches, ensuring a variety of craft beers and seasonal specialties. From traditional ales to innovative sour beers, there’s something for every beer enthusiast. Takeout options, available via phone and online ordering, make it easy to enjoy Appalachian Brewing Company’s offerings at home.
Whether a beer aficionado or simply looking for a great meal in a unique setting, Appalachian Brewing Company delivers on all fronts. The combination of quality craft beers, delicious food, and a historic location makes it a must-visit in Gettysburg.
Montezuma Mexican Restaurant
For flavorful Mexican cuisine, visit Montezuma Mexican Restaurant. Conveniently located at 225 Buford Avenue near a shopping center, this vibrant restaurant offers a casual dining experience with a lively atmosphere. The colorful Mexican art and traditional motifs add to the festive ambiance, making it a fun spot to enjoy a meal with friends or family.
The menu at Montezuma features a wide array of classic Mexican dishes, from tacos and enchiladas to fajitas, all made with authentic ingredients. Open daily for lunch and dinner, you can enjoy their delicious offerings anytime. Friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere make Montezuma popular with both locals and visitors.
In addition to an extensive menu, Montezuma offers a variety of drink options, including authentic margaritas and other cocktails. Whether celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, Montezuma Mexican Restaurant provides a delightful dining experience sure to satisfy your cravings.
Upper Crust Pizza
For a family-friendly dining experience in Gettysburg, Upper Crust is a fantastic choice. Located conveniently in town, this welcoming restaurant offers an atmosphere that is perfect for kids and adults alike. Known for its delicious pizzas, Upper Crust provides a casual and fun environment where families can enjoy a meal together.
The highlight of Upper Crust is its kid-friendly amenities, including free games that keep the little ones entertained while waiting for their food. This makes it an ideal spot for families looking to enjoy a relaxed dining experience without the worry of restless children.
The menu at Upper Crust focuses on a variety of pizzas, all crafted with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection. Whether you prefer classic toppings or more inventive combinations, there’s a pizza to satisfy every palate. In addition to pizza, the menu includes other options such as salads and sandwiches, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
With its welcoming atmosphere, great food, and family-friendly features, Upper Crust is a must-visit for anyone in Gettysburg looking for a delightful dining experience that caters to both kids and adults. It’s a place where you can enjoy quality time with your family while indulging in some of the best pizza in town.
Casual Bites
For those seeking a relaxed dining experience, the Springhouse Tavern at the Dobbin House is a perfect choice. Nestled within the historic Dobbin House, this cozy tavern offers a casual atmosphere that invites you to unwind and enjoy a meal in a setting rich with history. The rustic decor, complete with a welcoming fireplace, creates a warm and inviting ambiance that is perfect for a laid-back meal.
The Springhouse Tavern serves a variety of American-style cuisine, making it a versatile option for any palate. From hearty burgers and sandwiches to fresh salads, the menu offers something for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for classic pub fare or more substantial entrees, you’ll find a dish to satisfy your cravings.
Open daily from 11:30am to 9:00pm, the Springhouse Tavern does not accept reservations, so walk-ins are always welcome. Seating is available on a first-come, first-served basis, making it an ideal spot for spontaneous dining. The tavern also boasts a selection of wine, beer, and cocktails, perfect for enjoying a drink with your meal.
Whether you’re dining with family, friends, or solo, the Springhouse Tavern provides a relaxed and enjoyable dining experience in a historic setting. It’s a great spot to take a break from exploring Gettysburg and enjoy a delicious meal in a cozy, welcoming environment.
Summary of the Best Places to Eat Gettysburg
Gettysburg’s dining scene is as diverse and rich as its history. From the historic charm of Dobbin House Tavern to the refined elegance of Sidney Willoughby Run, and from the family-friendly atmosphere of Hickory Bridge Farm to the lively vibe of The Garryowen Irish Pub, there is something for everyone. Each restaurant offers a unique experience that combines excellent food with a distinctive ambiance, making Gettysburg a culinary destination worth exploring.
Whether you’re a history enthusiast, a foodie, or simply looking for a great place to eat, Gettysburg has a restaurant that will delight your senses and satisfy your appetite. So, the next time you visit this historic town, be sure to explore its top dining destinations and create your own memorable culinary adventure.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the oldest restaurant in Gettysburg?
Exciting news! The Dobbin House Tavern, established in 1776, is the oldest restaurant in Gettysburg!
Which restaurant in Gettysburg offers a farm-to-table dining experience?
Hickory Bridge Farm Restaurant is the place to be for an amazing farm-to-table dining experience, featuring a delicious seasonal menu that highlights local ingredients! You won’t want to miss this culinary gem!
What type of cuisine can I expect at The Garryowen Irish Pub?
You’ll love the authentic Irish cuisine at The Garryowen Irish Pub, featuring delicious dishes like shepherd’s pie and fish and chips! It’s a delightful taste of Ireland right at your doorstep!
Where can I find a modern dining experience with locally sourced ingredients in Gettysburg?
You’ll love dining at Food 101 in Gettysburg! They offer a fantastic modern experience with a menu focused on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients.
Which restaurant in Gettysburg has an extensive wine list?
You’ll love dining at Sidney Willoughby Run, where you can explore an incredible wine list boasting 6,000 bottles and award-winning selections! Cheers to a fantastic meal!
See more from Family Travel Unplugged!